What Contextualised Care Really Looks Like In Vet Practice. With Professor Jason Coe. #172
How can vets offer meaningful care options without losing the clarity of a recommendation? Professor Jason Coe joins us to explore contextualised care, client communication and shared decision-making in veterinary practice.
Using real case examples, they examine the human information a history can miss, how to explain the value of care, and when the visual Value Matrix can help clients compare options, practical demands and costs.
You’ve worked out what your patient needs. Or at least, what you’d ideally like to do. But you know that there are also other, more cost-effective options that could also get a good result.
So what do you tell the client? Do you give them only your one clear 'Plan A' recommendation, or do you lay out all the options and risk overwhelming them? And where does the money conversation fit?
My guest is Professor Jason Coe, a veterinarian and veterinary communication researcher at the University of Guelph’s Ontario Veterinary College. He’s spent two decades studying what happens between vets and clients, and how those conversations shape the care animals actually receive.
We work through real consult-room examples, from blocked cats to itchy dogs, to explore how clear recommendations and contextualised care can work together. Jason explains why the conversation starts well before we present a treatment plan, what we miss when our history only covers the animal, and how to explain the value of care beyond listing tests and prices.
We also unpack the Value Matrix, a practical way to put options, trade-offs and costs in front of a client without leaving them to make sense of it all on their own. And we tackle the fear underneath some of these decisions: what will our colleagues think if we don’t do everything?
I put my own consulting habits up for examination in this one, and Jason gave me plenty to think about, with some very practical things to try on your next shift.
Jason’s work and resources
- Relationship-Centred Veterinary Medicine resources: practical communication tools, including the Talking Physical Exam and resources for discussing care options.
- The Value Matrix: a video tutorial and accompanying publication on using this visual tool for shared decision-making.
- Clinical Communication Tools for Contextualizing Spectrum of Care: Jason and colleagues’ paper, with communication strategies and two worked case examples.
- VetEd Down Under, Melbourne, 2–5 February 2027: the veterinary education symposium mentioned in our conversation, featuring Jason on communication teaching.
- Drew Dudley’s Everyday Leadership TED talk: the “lollipop moments” idea behind Jason’s pass-along question.
Some help from the Vet Vault
Our Vet Vault clinical membership includes expert conversations across Medicine, Surgery and ECC, plus AI-powered search and practical clinical tools, like The Key to the Vet Vault, our blood gas interpreter and the new Australian snakebite “Danger Noodle” tool. Already a subscriber? Have a play with the tools included in your membership.
Come join us in person at our Adventure conferences in the snow in Italy and in the bush in Africa at Vets On Tour.
Episode guide
What does contextualised care mean in veterinary practice?
In this conversation, contextualised care means working with a client to choose an evidence-informed plan that fits the animal, the person and their circumstances. The spectrum of care provides possible diagnostic and treatment options; the consultation helps establish which options are appropriate and achievable for this particular patient and family.
Jason’s starting point is that there are two experts in the room. The vet brings medical expertise. The client brings knowledge of their animal, household and lived experience. A workable plan draws on both. His paper with Natasha Janke, Carol Gray and Ruth Serlin develops this approach through communication tools and worked case examples.
Can you offer options and still make a clear recommendation?
Yes. Jason distinguishes the process of reaching a decision from the clarity of the recommendation that follows it. Offering options does not mean handing over a price list and asking the client to choose unaided. It means discussing reasonable alternatives, explaining their advantages and disadvantages, and understanding what matters to the client before agreeing on the way forward.
Hugh describes his usual emergency approach: explain the preferred plan, give the estimate, then invite the client to raise concerns. Jason asks what was learnt about the person before that plan was formed. The practical shift is to bring that understanding into the decision earlier, so the recommendation already reflects the client’s situation.
The three history buckets: animal, environment and human
Jason encourages vets to gather information in three areas:
- Animal: the clinical history and patient factors that inform diagnosis, treatment and management.
- Environment: the household, other animals, routines and surroundings in which care will happen.
- Human: the client’s concerns, priorities, practical abilities and constraints.
The itchy-dog example makes the missing human information tangible. A plan may make medical sense, yet be difficult to carry out within the client’s daily routine. Finding out what has already been tried, what is happening at home and what is practical gives the vet something useful to build on.
Jason suggests starting broadly by inviting the client to walk through a typical day with their pet, then asking focused follow-up questions. In the nutrition example, asking for the whole day’s intake can uncover treats that a brand-focused food question misses. The evening treat may also be an important ritual between person and pet. Understanding that ritual helps the vet discuss a workable alternative.
How do you explain the value of veterinary care?
Jason separates the service being offered, the medical information it provides and what that information could mean for the animal. Naming a blood test and its price tells the client what they are buying. Explaining how the result could guide a decision, and how that decision could affect their pet’s wellbeing, makes its purpose clearer.
Hugh tests this with a blocked-cat scenario and a discussion about ultrasound. Jason encourages a comparison of the available approaches, including their risks and uncertainties, before asking the client to decide. The example explores how to communicate a decision; the appropriate investigation still depends on the individual case.
Jason’s proposed sequence is to discuss the options and relevant patient and client considerations, then introduce cost so the prices have context. Finances remain part of the decision alongside the benefits, burdens and uncertainties of each option.
How to use the Value Matrix
The Value Matrix puts the comparison onto a whiteboard or piece of paper so the client can see it as well as hear it. Jason outlines a simple process:
- List the reasonable care options down the left-hand side.
- Put relevant patient and client considerations across the top, such as expected benefit, invasiveness, medication requirements or return visits.
- Use ticks, crosses, question marks or brief explanations to show how the options compare, including where the answer is uncertain.
- Invite the client to add considerations that matter to them, then include costs and discuss the choice together.
A client who cannot easily travel, for example, may reveal that the number of return visits needs its own column. The matrix can change as new information emerges. Jason also uses it to organise a clinician’s thinking and help teams rehearse common conversations.
It need not be used for every decision. Jason describes clients responding positively to the tool while wanting it used selectively, particularly when a choice is complex or difficult.
Does relationship-centred consulting take more time?
Jason acknowledges that time is a real pressure and describes mixed findings across communication research. His argument is that learning about the client early may reduce later work trying to repair a recommendation that does not fit.
He also describes a simulated consultation study comparing a drawn Value Matrix with the same information delivered verbally, reporting no significant difference in time. That comparison concerns a simulation with controlled information. It does not establish that every real consultation will be quicker, or prove improved patient outcomes.
Helping colleagues feel comfortable offering alternatives
The conversation also explores fear of peer judgement and the distress of offering care that differs from the ideal a vet was taught. Jason argues for supportive team conversations about reasonable options and informed client consent.
When Hugh describes reviewing another vet’s overnight case, Jason cautions against judging a consultation neither of them witnessed. A more useful team discussion asks what influenced the decision and what could be explored in a similar case next time. His closing theme is that practising these conversations and supporting one another are part of the change.
One thing to try on your next shift
Before presenting a plan, identify one piece of human or household context that could affect whether it will work. Use that information when explaining the reasonable options. If the comparison becomes difficult to follow, draw it out together and ask what consideration is still missing.
RSS Feed